Employers turning down flexible working requests is prompting a growing number of indirect sex or disability discrimination claims. Here’s some guidance on how to handle flexible working requests as an employer.

With a steady rise of flexible working requests in the workplace, employers are facing increasing pressure to keep employees happy, treat them all fairly and ensure their actions make commercial sense for the business.

By law, all employees have the right to request flexible working – not just parents and carers – if they have worked for the same employer for at least 26 weeks. This is known as ‘making a statutory application’.

As an employer, you are permitted to deal with flexible working requests in a ‘reasonable manner’

This means assessing the advantages and disadvantages of the application, holding a meeting to discuss the request with the employee and offering an appeal process. If an employer does not handle a request in a reasonable manner, the employee can take employers to an employment tribunal. However, it is still difficult for flexible working requests to be successful as a stand-alone claim, unless there is a violation of process.

Sex discrimination has been prohibited under UK law since 1975, but unfair dismissal remains the most common reason for claims with many more expected now that furlough has ended. Many of these claims are around how employers are treating women, either on maternity leave or those about to begin maternity leave. However, it is important to note that these issues are not just confined to women. Employers should be aware that men can also request flexible working and you no longer have to be a carer of a child or relative to do so – it can be for personal choice. With that in mind, many rejected flexible working requests are leading to indirect discrimination cases, most commonly sex and disability claims.

An employer can refuse an application if they have a good business reason for doing so

If, as an employer, you decide to decline an employee’s flexible working request, you are required to give a proscribed reason, giving thought to the commercial risks of declining the request and the possibility that you may lose the employee even if the request doesn’t result in a tribunal claim.

It can be difficult for employers to achieve a balance and make fair decisions when faced with multiple requests within the organisation, especially when requests made for childcare reasons could be riskier to decline compared to those made for personal reasons.

It has become harder for employers to decline such applications since flexible working was generally regarded as a success during the pandemic. With that in mind, many organisations have recently announced increased flexible working as a standard. However, the detrimental impact that remote working has had on customer service in some industries (longer waiting times, lack of face-to-face engagement, technology issues) is one of the proscribed reasons to decline a request for flexible working.

Thomas Dunton has been providing specialist legal advice to both employers and employees on all kinds of employment issues for over 40 years. These include redundancy, dismissals, grievances, preparation of documentation such as employment contracts, and guidance on the implement of procedures and regulations. If you have a employment matter you would like legal advice on, please contact our team on 0800 3582757 or email us at employment@thomasdunton.co.uk. See what sets us apart here.

Read more latest news and industry insights. 

 

Keep in touch

To receive our newsletters and details of our talks and events:

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.