The High Court has ruled that a child born via an overseas surrogate can be included as a beneficiary of family trusts, highlighting how evolving family structures are challenging traditional legal definitions.
The case was brought by Ceawlin Thynn, the 8th Marquess of Bath, and his wife, Emma Thynn, who sought court approval for their second son, Henry, to be recognised as a beneficiary of three family trusts. Although genetically their child, Henry was born in the United States in 2016 through a surrogate, following medical complications during the Marchioness’s first pregnancy.
The court considered whether Henry fell within the trusts’ definition of eligible beneficiaries. These trusts relied on pre-1970 common law language, using terms such as “child,” “grandchild,” and “issue,” which predate modern reproductive technologies, including IVF and surrogacy.
In his judgment after a hearing in Bristol, Judge Paul Matthews approved the trustees’ proposed use of their powers to include Henry as a beneficiary. However, he clarified that this decision did not determine any immediate financial entitlement. Instead, any future distributions would need to take into account potential tax implications, particularly given Henry’s birth in the United States to an American surrogate.
The judge also noted that the court was not asked to definitively rule on the broader legal status of children born through surrogacy under traditional common law definitions. As such, this remains an area of legal uncertainty.
The ruling underscores the growing need for trust law to adapt to modern family arrangements, as courts increasingly confront cases that existing legal frameworks were not designed to address.
Read the full article at Today’s Family Lawyer.
Read more on family and children law and how Thomas Dunton Solicitors can help.