A High Court judge has ruled that a will made by a 93-year-old woman with advanced dementia is invalid, citing serious concerns over undue influence and the conduct of the will writer.
The case centred on Peggy Dalton, who executed a new will in November 2020, just four months before her death. The document marked a dramatic departure from her 2018 will, disinheriting one son, and leaving almost her entire £600,000 estate to her other son and his wife.
Court Findings
Master Katherine McQuail declared the 2020 will invalid on multiple grounds, including:
- Lack of proper execution
- Lack of testamentary capacity
- Lack of knowledge and approval
- Undue influence by her other son and his wife (the beneficiaries of the estate)
The court found that by late 2020, Peggy was suffering from significant cognitive decline due to dementia and was unable to properly understand the nature and consequences of making a will.
Concerns Over Undue Influence
Evidence presented showed that her son and wife had moved into Peggy’s home earlier in 2020 and assumed control of her affairs under a power of attorney. During this time, Peggy became increasingly isolated from other family members, social care professionals, and medical support.
The court heard allegations that false information had been conveyed to Peggy, including claims that her son (the beneficiary) had stolen money and attempted to kill his brother. These claims were found to have no factual basis.
The judge concluded that Peggy’s beliefs were either the result of confusion caused by her condition or the product of misinformation, raising serious doubts about her ability to make independent decisions.
Ultimately, the court determined that any remaining capacity Peggy may have had was overridden by the influence of her son and his wife, and that the will reflected their wishes rather than her own.
Criticism of the Will Writer
The will writer involved in drafting the document also came under significant criticism. The judge highlighted:
- A failure to assess Peggy’s mental capacity
- No evidence of private discussion with Peggy
- No medical input to verify her ability to make a will
Despite the will writer’s note stating Peggy was “not under duress,” the judge dismissed this, stating there was “no credibility” in his assessment.
Outcome
The court reinstated Peggy’s 2018 will, which divided her estate between both sons. Her son and his wife were also ordered to pay his brother’s legal costs, estimated at approximately £190,000.
Key Takeaways
This case highlights the legal risks surrounding late-life changes to wills, particularly where:
- The testator is vulnerable or cognitively impaired
- There is a significant change from previous arrangements
- Family members play a dominant role in decision-making
- Proper professional safeguards are not followed
It serves as a strong reminder of the importance of independent advice, thorough capacity assessments, and clear documentation when preparing wills, especially for elderly or vulnerable individuals.
Explore the importance of safeguarding and planning for your future.