Talk to the China Club
by Catherine Crabtree — 24 November 2015
Thank you all for inviting me to give a talk to you on the subject of
Wills and Lasting Powers of Attorney. I know that the Chinese
community in Orpington is growing rapidly and I am looking forward
to getting to know you all a little better.
I plan to spend the next hour or so running you through some
of the things you will need to consider before coming to see a
solicitor to make your Will. I will start with the basics and get
progressively more complicated … if at any time you would
like me to stop and explain something more fully, please interrupt
me and ask me to go over it.
This talk will only be worthwhile if I can give you information
you didn’t have before, so please ask as many questions as possible.
Benefits of making a Will
What is a Will?
In its simplest terms, a Will is a document which allows you to
specify during your lifetime who should receive your assets
(your money and property) after your death.
Freedom of choice
It is important to understand that English law allows a person full
freedom to leave their money and possessions to anyone they
choose.
The law does not force me to leave anything to any person,
regardless of my relationship with them. For example, I have
a husband, children and parents.
But if I wanted to leave everything I own to a childhood
friend, I could do so. I could make a Will leaving my family
nothing at all. I do not have to provide for any members of my
family if I do not want to.
However, if I were to make a Will leaving nothing to my family
or other people dependant on me, these people might be able
to apply to court for some provision to be made from my estate
after my death – effectively asking for my Will to be changed in
their favour one way or another. But there is no guarantee that
they would succeed.
Even if they did succeed, the court would not say that I was wrong
to have written my Will as I had.
So an English Will really does start off as a blank document.
It is up to you to choose what you want to put in it.
Avoid intestacy
So, once you have decided who you want to benefit from your
Assets after your death, it is important that you do everything
possible to ensure that this happens. The only way to do this
is by making a Will.
If you die without making a Will, you will be considered to
be dying intestate. This means that the law dictates how your
assets are distributed after your death. Your money and property
will go to certain categories of people, even if it is quite obvious
that these would not be the people who you would have wanted
to benefit.
So, making a Will is important to make sure that your wishes
are put into effect after your death.
Providing carefully for your family
You know your own family best. It may be that you know that one
person in your family has greater needs than another and you
want to make sure that this person is properly looked after once
you have died. A Will allows you to do this.
Children
You may have a child in your family and want to make sure that he
or she is properly looked after if you die. I often think that this is the
most important thing to address when making a Will. A Will allows
you to appoint a guardian for that child – someone who knows the
child and who you trust to bring him or her up in the way you want.
Many people want to leave money for children after their death –
sometimes their own children, and sometimes grandchildren.
If you do this in your Will, you can control the age at which a child
can inherit. A child who inherits under the intestacy laws will
automatically inherit at the age of 18. However, many people feel
that 18 is not the best age to come into large sums of money.
If you make a Will, you can set the age at which a child can have
full rights over their money – perhaps 21 or 25. Before this age,
the money will be held for them in trust, by someone who you
appoint to manage their money on their behalf. This could be
a friend or a relative, or a professional if you prefer.
These trustees can forward sums of money to the children (or their
guardians) if they need it for the children’s education, maintenance
or benefit, but otherwise will keep control of it until they reach
the age you have chosen. This allows you to have some confidence
that the money won’t be wasted by foolish youthful decisions.
Planning for inheritance tax
If you do not have a Will, then you might find that the intestacy rules
mean that your money is being left in a way which gives rise to a
greater charge to tax on your estate. I will talk about inheritance tax
much more in a minute, but I want to emphasise that tax planning
is a very important part of making a Will. Some time spent with an
advisor now may lead to great savings later for your estate.
What if I don’t speak English?
Not speaking English should not be a barrier to making a Will.
If you have English assets, then you probably need an English Will.
However, there are some problems which will need to be overcome
if you don’t speak or understand English. You will need to bring a
translator with you, as unfortunately, I don’t speak either Cantonese
or Mandarin!
If you bring a translator with you, I will want to be sure of two things.
Firstly, that the translator will respect your confidentiality as much as
I will. Secondly, that the translator is not putting any pressure on you
to leave your estate one way or another.
Unfortunately, these two things sometimes conflict. The people who
you trust to translate for you and keep your affairs secret are often
the same people to whom you will be planning to leave money. But if
those people are present when we are talking, then it is going to be
difficult for me to be sure that you are not feeling bullied into leaving
them money because they are there listening to our conversation.
If your Will is ever challenged after your death, it may be by
someone who claims that you didn’t feel free to leave your money as
you wanted because another member of your family was forcing you
to give me instructions in their favour. This challenge will be made
much stronger if that member of the family was actually there in the
room with us as you gave me your instructions.
So, I suggest that you consider carefully who to bring along as your
translator. If you want a member of your family to come, that may be
OK. But if you are planning to do anything unusual with your Will –
for example, to exclude one member of your family – then I suggest
that you choose someone independent instead.
If any challenge is later made, my notes will then show that you were
able to speak to me freely without being influenced by any person
who was to benefit from your Will.
Will my Will cover my overseas assets?
This is a straightforward question with a rather complicated answer!
The answer is … it depends. It depends partly on you and your
situation,and it depends partly on what the overseas assets are.
If you have moved to England permanently and have a clear intention
to spend the rest of your life here, then some of your overseas assets
may be covered by your English Will.
If your overseas assets are in moveable things (like bank accounts),
rather than immoveable things (like property), then they may be able
to be covered by your English Will.
Very roughly, the position can be summed up like this:
- Any land or buildings overseas will probably not be covered by an English Will.
- Any bank accounts overseas might be covered by an English Will, but only if you plan to live in England for the rest of your life.
- If you are not English by birth and do not plan to live in England for the rest of your life, then probably none of your overseas assets will be covered by your English Will.
If you come to see me, then I can talk through your particular
situation with you and we will be able to have a clearer idea of
what will and will not be covered.
It may well be wise to make a separate Will back home to
sit alongside your English Will.
Inheritance tax – worldwide assets
Inheritance tax is a tax which is payable by your estate after you die.
It will certainly be chargeable on your UK assets and (depending on
your particular situation) it may be chargeable on every asset you
own worldwide.
Inheritance tax is triggered when assets are left to people known as
“chargeable beneficiaries”. Chargeable beneficiaries are essentially
people who are not a spouse or a charity. So, if you leave assets to
children, siblings, friends etc, you will be leaving them to chargeable
beneficiaries.
The basic position is this: Each person can leave up to £325,000 to
chargeable beneficiaries without having to pay inheritance tax.
Anything left over this will be taxed at 40%. To put a bit of flesh
on this, imagine a single person, leaving her entire estate worth
£525,000 to her nieces. The nieces are chargeable beneficiaries and
so the inheritance tax regime will apply. The first £325,000 will be
taxfree, but the remaining £200,000 will be charged to tax at 40%.
This will leave the estate with a tax bill of £80,000 to pay before the
nieces inherit.
The position is a bit rosier for married couples. A spouse is not a
chargeable beneficiary. So you can leave as much as you like to a
spouse without any charge to tax. If you have several million, then
you can leave this several million to your husband or wife, and there
will be no tax to pay.
Even better, because the spouse is not a chargeable beneficiary,
you have not used your nilrate band (the £325,000 allowance).
This is not lost, however. When your spouse dies, his or her estate
can claim your unused £325,000 nil-rate band on top of his or
her own. This gives married couples a combined nilrate band of
£650,000 which can be passed down to chargeable beneficiaries,
tax-free.
Recent announcements from the government have made the
position a little more complicated. However, for many people,
the more complicated rules will work in their favour.
The announcements are to do with a new scheme known as the
“residential nil-rate band” which will be introduced in April 2017
and come fully in force in April 2020.
Details of the residential nil-rate band are still rather few on
the ground. However, what weknow so far is this. If you die and
leave property (ie a house) to direct descendants (children,
grandchildren, step-children), then there will be an additional
nil-rate band available (from 2020) of £175,000 per person.
So, to go back to the example above. If our single person dies in
April 2020 with her estate (including a house) worth £525,000
leaving it all to her nieces, her position will not change. If, however,
she leaves it to her children, then she will now have two nil-rate
bands to use. She will have her nil-rate band of £325,000 and also
the £175,000 residential nilrate band. This means that she can leave
£500,000 free of tax. It will then only be the £25,000 which will
be taxed – giving her estate a tax bill of £10,000 … a much better
position than before.
Now, if this person were not a single person but a widow whose
husband had died before her leaving his estate to her, then her
estate would be able to claim not only her own nil-rate band and
residential nil-rate band, but also her husband’s nil-rate band
and residential nilrate band. This gives her a total nilrate band of
£1,000,000. As she is only leaving £525,000, this is all covered
by the nil-rate band and there will be no tax to pay on her estate.
Avoiding inheritance tax
Having navigated through these complicated rules, is there anything
you can do if you think your estate is going to be subject to tax?
Yes, there may be – and I suggest that you come in to discuss this
with me.
In some circumstances, tax can be avoided or reduced by making
appropriate lifetime gifts of capital or income; by dealing
appropriately with inheritances received from other people, or by
making wise gifts to charity. However, there is not one trick which
works appropriately for each person, so bespoke advice on these
points is generally sensible.
Reviewing an existing Will
If you already have a Will in place, that’s good news. However, it is
never advisable to forget about your Will.
We suggest that you should review your Will every 3-5 years.
Changes occur, both in personal situations and in the law, and a
Will which was appropriate once may no longer be appropriate now.
To give an example: imagine a person who has been widowed and
makes a Will leaving everything to his children. He then meets
and marries a new wife. He is still committed to his children and
wants to leave them everything, and so he does not change his Will.
However, if he does not review his Will with an advisor, his
children will be in for a nasty surprise on his death. When he
married his new wife, his existing Will was revoked by law.
As he has not made a new Will, he will die intestate, and the rules
of intestacy will leave much of his estate to his new wife.
So, without intending to, he has disinherited his children.
Another example relates to Wills which were made for tax-planning
a few years ago. The law on inheritance tax has changed
substantially over the last decade and Wills which were well
advised ten years ago can now be actively disadvantageous, resulting
in a higher eventual tax bill.
So the moral of the story is this: Once your Will is written, don’t put it
away and forget about it. Bring it out and check it every few years,
and if you have any questions, come and see us.
Lasting Powers of Attorney
Now I want to move on from Wills. I’ve talked a lot about what is
going to happen to your money after you die. I want to move
on to possibly a far more important question: what will happen
to you if you are still alive, but have lost your ability to make
your own decisions?
This is called losing capacity in legal terms and it can cause many
problems.
For example, imagine that you own property and have some savings.
You then have a stroke which affects your mind. You are extremely
vulnerable – possibly the most vulnerable you have ever been.
You need your savings to be spent on your own care, and you
need them urgently. However, there’s a problem. Your savings
are all safely in the bank account. But the only person who can
operate that bank account is you … and you’re in no state to do so.
This is a difficult and real problem. If someone else wants to help you,
then they can apply to the court for an order to access your assets.
But this is a long (and costly) exercise.
The solution is to enter into a document called a Lasting Power of
Attorney for property & financial affairs. This is a document
which you enter into now whilst you are mentally sound. In this
document, you choose people who you trust to be able to access
your bank accounts. Many people choose their children, but
sometimes people choose friends or other relatives.
These appointed people will then be able to take control of your
affairs at any time you choose, or when you lose capacity.
They are not able to spend the money on themselves, but only
on you and your care and they have to act in your best interests
at all times.
This means that if you find yourself in this vulnerable situation,
your assets can be used for you at the time at which you need it most.
There are, in fact, two documents which deal with the decisions
which need to be made if you lose capacity. The one I have just
been speaking about is the one which deals with your property
and financial affairs. There is a second one which deals with
the decisions to be made about your health and welfare.
This is similar in many ways. It allows you to choose now the
people who you would like to make decisions on your behalf
connected with your care if you lose capacity. These decisions
can be choices about where you live or how you are cared for,
and can (if you choose) include decisions about whether or not
you should receive life-sustaining treatment.
Many people find it a relief to know that if they lose capacity,
these decisions will be taken by people they love, rather than a
medical team. For example, some people feel strongly that if
they lose capacity, they would not like to be treated for any illness
which comes along, but simply allowed to die in as much comfort
as possible. A Lasting Power of Attorney for health and welfare
would allow them to give these instructions to their attorneys.
Their attorneys would then have the power to insist upon this
if the situation arises.
This brings my talk to an end.
Thank you for listening to me. I’m sure that there is plenty here
which is new to you, so please feel free to ask me as many questions
as you like. I shall be here for a little time afterwards, so if you would
like to have a quick chat with me individually, I’ll be happy to do so.